Why Magazine Advertising Works: The Power of Top-of-Mind Awareness

You’ve probably heard it before—“I tried advertising once, but I didn’t get any calls.” It’s a common response, and one that we completely understand. As a business owner, you want results. You want your phone to ring, your website traffic to spike, or your storefront to fill up. But here’s the thing:

Advertising isn’t always about what happens immediately. It’s about what happens when someone needs you.

And that’s where Top-of-Mind Awareness comes in.

What Is Top-of-Mind Awareness?

Top-of-Mind Awareness (TOMA) is the marketing sweet spot. It means your business is the first one people think of when they need a product or service you offer.

Let’s say someone says, “I’m looking for a great place to eat in the Black Hills,” or “Do you know a local painter or contractor?” If your name pops into their head—or even better, if a friend mentions your business without hesitation—you’ve built top-of-mind awareness.

And how do you get there?

Repetition. Visibility. Consistency.

Why Magazine Advertising Supports Top-of-Mind Awareness

In a world where digital ads are here one second and gone the next, print media—especially magazines—offers a different kind of value. Here’s why magazine ads are still an important piece of the marketing puzzle:

1. Magazines Are Trusted and Tangible

Print feels permanent and credible. People trust what they see in print,, and they spend more time with it. Magazines often sit on kitchen counters and coffee tables for days, even weeks, offering repeated exposure to your ad.

2. Repetition Builds Recognition

The first time someone sees your ad, they may not need you. But by the second or third time, your name becomes familiar. And familiarity leads to trust, which leads to action when the timing is right.

3. You Reach the Right People

Magazines like Black Hills Community Connection are mailed directly to local households, not random online users. These are real people in your community—your neighbors, future customers, and ideal audience.

4. Readers Are Engaged

Unlike online ads that are scrolled past or blocked, magazine readers are more focused. They’re intentionally reading, flipping pages, and absorbing what they see. This results in higher ad recall and stronger brand connections.

“But I Didn’t Get Any Calls…”

It’s a fair concern, and here’s what we tell our advertisers:

Advertising is like planting seeds.

You won’t always see instant growth, but you’re building something that lasts. When someone is finally ready to buy, they’ll remember the name they’ve seen consistently—yours.

Also, keep in mind that advertising works in layers. Your magazine ad supports your website. Your website supports your social media. Your social media supports word-of-mouth. It’s all connected, and visibility across multiple channels is key.

Final Thoughts

If you're only advertising when you're slow, you’ll stay slow.

The most successful local businesses understand that consistent visibility leads to long-term success.

Magazine advertising is about more than just a phone call today. It's about becoming the name people remember tomorrow—and the one they trust when they’re ready to take action.

Ready to start building your brand’s presence in the Black Hills? Let’s chat about how you can get in front of 80,000+ local households through Black Hills Community Connection and other Local Black Hills platforms.

Your feedback is important to us

What do you think of this blog post? Leave us a comment!